Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Zara IT & POS Channel Upgrade Consultant Lead In



Problem/Issue Statement:

As Xan Salgado Badas and Bruno Sanchez Ocampo discussed the future growth of Zara and the viability and sustainability of their current operating model they realized they had fundamental disagreements on the future of the current IT system in place at Zara. Zara operates the largest chain of stores within Inditex and is growing across Europe and other territories at the rate of one store per day so the IT system in place for POS channels and communication is vital to organization future success. Salgado, the head of IT for Zara and Sanchez, the lead for the POS system, disagreed on whether or not the current POS system and certain IT infrastructure needed to be replaced and updated. Salgado believes the investment needs to center around the current POS system along with a general upgrade in the IT infrastructure to enhance certain capabilities. Sanchez, however, believes the investment is not warranted at the current time as he believes the POS system provides the necessary information and capabilities for the continuing of Zara’s business model. The two men have a fundamental disagreement in the current state of the IT system in use. Salgado believes the company runs a great risk of falling behind the wave of technology using outdated systems, mainly with the suppliers of their hardware should they choose to stop manufacturing the terminal components. Furthermore, Salgado states his displeasure for the limited capabilities of the system as well as the lack of communication and analysis of certain data. Sanchez, however, trusts in the notion that if it is not broke, don’t fix it. He feels that the current operating model is satisfied with the IT systems in place and it has supported the tremendous growth to this point, so a large investment and the learning curve associated with the system is simply too large of an investment and risk.
It is important to note that although the current system has proven to be very reliable and it does currently satisfy the needs of the business model; the POS terminal application runs on DOS, an archaic system that is not supported by the major software suppliers such as Microsoft. Zara simply writes custom applications that run on DOS to date. Although the current suppliers of the hardware for the POS system have no plan of action to discontinue these parts, they also aren’t willing to be placed in a long-term contract for producing the hardware components. This leaves Zara in a vulnerable position if the supplier chooses to no longer produce the hardware, leaving them with a short, finite amount of hardware, which could limit future expansion for a period of time. Other issues besides the possibility of suppliers choosing to no longer produce the hardware and the archaic nature of DOS also reside in the capabilities of the application. For instance, employees cannot check real-time inventories or the inventories in nearby stores, while also spending excessive time on recording information manually into PDA’s and transferring that and other information to other hardware on one modem for transmission. It is also important to note that the POS system not only affects the individual store that would possibly upgrade its systems, but virtually the entire value chain for Zara. The POS system has certain interactions at nearly every level and impact on the overall business model so the investment is large as well is the risk.

Assessment of Issue:  

It is evident that Zara operates on a model that creates a competitive advantage through speed and adaptability. Zara has excelled at the challenge of not only staying up to date with current market trends of apparel, but also capitalizing on these trends by having that apparel on the shelves as quickly as possible. The company does not sell these clothes over their internet site, as it is for display purposes only, so sales through its outlets are the only transactions that occur. This further places an emphasis on having the correct inventories and correct apparel on the shelves within the least amount of time possible. Zara further complements this strategy by offering clothes that comply with current market trends and are not “classic” trends that may be around for longer periods of time. This ensures the company will release trends virtually on a bi-weekly basis while offering short periods of sale items as well limited inventories, all to encourage the customer to ‘buy now.’ Zara also intends its clothing to be worn a limited amount of times (roughly 10 times) before it is worn down or out of style. All of these factors push customers for quick and timely impulse buying patterns and often repeat customers. As mentioned above, Zara is opening outlets at the rate of one store per day, and they see great opportunities for expansion in certain markets, particularly Italy. As Zara looks to continuing expanding operations the IT system would presumably become more sophisticated as the need for greater communication becomes larger. As it presently operates, a Zara outlet could be opened (in terms of the POS channels) simply by installing several floppy disks with the POS and applications onto the hardware. Even if irregularities were presented or malfunctions in the installation a standard re-installation was fairly simple. This process limits the need for an expansive IT division. When considering the possible upgrade or IT systems as solutions Zara should keep in mind that it follows a track record and business model that says ‘close is good enough’ and being exactly precise is not necessary and often costly. This means a process that would increase the time of the flow of information, employee downtime, or trying to develop exact counts and analysis would relegate a competitive advantage they currently operate with. They also need to consider whether or not the actual investment, likely down time or learning curve of the upgrade is worth the potential loss of sales and the risk associated with switching from a proven process to a new system.

Possible Alternatives/ Solutions:

Solutions for the IT system at hand for Zara revolve around two main possibilities:

First, Zara could use the “if it’s not broken, don’t fix it” approach. This would obviously entail Zara moving forward with the current DOS Operating System with custom applications and the POS channels. As mentioned, the means Zara could continue without disrupting the model that has been proven to be very successful with no further investment to the current system, no learning curve, and no switching costs or risks associated with upgrading. The company, however, will run the risk of a limited source of components should the supplier choose to stop producing the hardware. Furthermore, they would continue to be limited in the actual capabilities that the system allows them to harness such as interaction between stores and visibility of actual inventories. They would continue to operate on the single modem model platform which to an effect could limit productivity due the lack of a wireless network and computer interaction. Should Zara choose to stay within this system it also creates the situation of whether or not they should invest in buying more hardware and components in case the supplier chooses to shut down those particular operations. This investment would ensure they would be sticking with the DOS platform for some time to come due to the capital investment and also would provide a future number of possible of sites with guaranteed start up hardware.

Secondly, Zara could push forward with the investment and the upgrade of the IT infrastructure as well as the current POS channels. This option provides the upside of potential new capabilities that could enhance productivity and interaction among outlets. This would most likely entail moving from the dated DOS platform to current software such as Windows, Linux, or Unix. Not only would certain POS channels be upgraded but an upgrade in equipment with wireless networking and computers would likely accompany the system. This could potentially increase productivity moving from the PDA to the functions of a computer. This would also allow for greater interaction among stores (for out of stocks, product transfers, or inquiries) as well as more exact inventory accounts for personnel.  This however does come at a sizeable investment financially. When considering programming for the OS switch (450 Euros/Day), POS channel upgrades, and labor for the physical upgrade (roughly 32 hours) the capital outlay is considerable. Perhaps more importantly than some of these capital outlays are the opportunity costs that accompany the upgrade. Due to the associated learning curve, fixing potential glitches in the new system, and employee training Zara could stand to lose millions in sales as a result of stores across Europe not being operationally for even a few days. Also, the familiarity associated with the current system with managers, employees, analysts, and manufactures has an inherited value that could be disrupted as well as create unwanted disturbance among those who are against switching from a proven process.

Recommendation:
It would be in my initial assessment that I would recommend that Zara currently forgo the investment and upgrade and stay with the current IT infrastructure. It appears that the capital investment and associated risk with the upgrade outweigh the limited benefits that accompany it. Although the store interaction, wireless networking, accurate inventory counts, and increased functionality of the upgraded equipment are beneficial features to have within an IT system, it is not necessary to have due to Zara’s business model. They have proven that the current model has not only been proven successful, but also shows signs of viability and sustainability in the future. I also believe working with the suppliers to persuade them into a long-term contract to produce the current hardware would be extremely beneficial for long-term security. Even if the contract does not come to fruition, Zara could look to make a small capital investment of components to be used in the Italy expansion of outlets in order to secure the systems sustainability for future growth. Zara may need to ultimately make the switch away from DOS and the current components towards Windows or Linux, but the investment is not needed at this time and can be ultimately decided upon once they receive confirmation the supply of the components is finite. Zara has thrived on the ‘close is good enough’ model, short product turnaround time, and limited inventories. The upgrade and its associated risk, learning curve, possible employee downtime and limited customer interaction at this particular time seem to outweigh the benefits of the upgrade.  


Friday, February 22, 2013

1-888-JUNK-Van Case Reflective

Team,

As a follow up to the business meeting with the consultants on the topic of upgrading our IT systems in order to stabilize our current business model while looking towards future, sustainable growth I have the following thoughts and considerations for our meeting tomorrow. As I discussed in my pre-consultation evaluation the consulting team described in detail each of the possible solutions to our current IT system that's in place; from Google Docs and custom applications to ERP and PaaS. It became quite evident to me that a number of the systems could be ruled out as possible solutions. When keeping in mind the most important characteristics of a system we would like to implement such as cost, flexibility, implementation time, vendor support, and very importantly minimizing the complexity of the IT system  it became evident that PaaS would be the most intriguing option for upgrade. We must consider the fact that although we are looking to grow the franchise we are still a small business operating in a unique business environment that does not require the implementation of a sophisticated and complex IT system that will need a large infrastructure and understanding to support and operate the application. I am ideally looking to put in place a system that can handle the business processes we currently operate with the flexibility for future adjustments, if needed. PaaS clearly satisfies these needs of the business while requiring minimal implementation time, competitive cost, and third part support and management. I have full faith this will correct out current information handling and data errors while creating the opportunity for management of the business to focus on growing our franchise, as well as other vital functions of the company. It would also be prudent to note that the system outlined by the consulting team as well as my initial research described PaaS as the desired solution, however the system actually follows the guidelines and characteristics of Software as a Service (SaaS), mainly because there is no physical hardware for the system on our end. I look forward to hearing all your thoughts and feedback from the meeting last night as well as any other immediate concerns to consider, such as the process of accounts receivable.

Thank you,

Brian Grau

Monday, February 18, 2013

1-888-JUNK-VAN Consultant Lead-In

Team,

As a precursor to our highly anticipated meeting with the consulting team this week, I would like to provide a review and assessment of the state of our business. Although I truly believe we have a proven and successful business model and optimistic future forecast, I do believe there are a series of legitimate holes in our business structure as it operates in the current environment. Without the correction of these issues, not only do we risk the future growth of the business, but we also risk the viability of the business as it currently operates. As an overview of our current business environment; it is clear the waste management industry has been through a cycle in terms of annual growth. From 2000-2009 the compound annual growth rate of 2.5% showed promise for the industry, however since then the industry has only grown by a CAGR of 0.6%. Promise is on the horizon however as experts believe the industry value will reach $276.4 billion by 2014 due to a CAGR of 3.9% over the next five years. Due to the nature of this industry, where clients largely consider the service a commodity, offering exceptional professional service at the lowest possible rates are imperative for the growth of the business. In order to offer exceptional professional service while also charging industry-low rates the business must excel in the areas of operational  efficiency and information processing. It has become evident the current state of our IT system, within the MS-Works database, is creating a situation that is producing an unacceptable number of information handling errors, database errors, and broken communications internally that is leading to poor customer service and the loss of current and potential clients. An array of possible solutions are available to upgrade or replace our current IT systems, each with potential strengths and drawbacks. It is most important that we put in place a system that will handle the business information accurately on a timely-basis and that could be implemented as quickly as possible. Several other characteristics of the potential system that are highly desirable include the complexity to handle our current business model while having the flexibility to change with the demands of the marketplace as well as vendor support to ensure the correct implementation now and in the future.

Using the following matrix I have provided an overview and assessment of the possible alternatives to our current IT system. As mentioned above it would be prudent for the team to assess each alternative with the most important characteristics we are looking for in the IT system as well as the applied risk and investment of each system. Lastly, we do not want to sacrifice the viability and sustainability of the future growth of the organization for short term profits and implementation.


As you can see from the evaluation matrix, given the general numerical scores I assessed to each solution, Platform as a Service (Paas) would be a solution with the greatest benefits to our business model. PaaS is similar to Google Docs in that the information is delivered on a cloud-computing infrastructure. This service hosts a bevy of potential benefits with few drawbacks. Users of the software could access the information and applications on demand from any connected device (using current laptops, smart phones, etc). This means utilizing common documents as well as the ability to build new unique applications, on a platform hosted by a third party. Based on initial research and demonstration trials from potential providers, it appears the forms and tables have a short learning-curve and implementation and data migration could be in place within three days. It also appears that Paas is gaining a great deal of momentum and endorsement from experts in the industry. The package is priced moderately at $300-$600 per month depending on variables such as the number of users and storage. Further customization, however, would require an increase in cost ($180/hour) and implementation time. Lastly, a nice feature is that the provider does not require long-term contracts, while offering various service levels and cancellation within one month. These features would allow us to mitigate our risk of the investment. Due to the numerous benefits stated above, as well as a lower risk associated with the investment than the other possible solutions, initial insights would point to implementing PaaS to upgrade our IT infrastructure.

Further analysis into utilizing MS Access, a custom built application software, Google Docs, and ERP as possible solution needs to be considered as they each offer unique benefits. It would also be prudent to learn more on the topic of hiring a dedicated IT worker to analyze, interpret, and distribute the company's data. This choice would likely be too expensive and may not be a long-term solution, however I would like to garner the thoughts from the consulting team.

Thank you and I look forward to the meeting on Tuesday,

Brian Grau