Team,
As a follow up to
our consultant meeting on the topic of a possible system implementation and
upgrade to COBIT 5 I have the following thoughts before we move towards making
a final decision. As stated in my initial pre-meeting notes and reiterated by
the consultants, this is a major investment for our firm and is a significant
decisions in regards of the future development and direction of our information
technology systems. For several key reasons I still maintain the position that
it is not the time for Accenture to go ahead with the implementation of COBIT 5
standards.
It is important to
remind ourselves the actual tangible benefit we could obtain versus the
investment costs. When taking a closer look at the initial capital
outlays plus future investments needed to maintain the COBIT 5 implementation I
simply believe that the costs outweigh the benefits. My initial research
provided insights into a total investment that could easily reach
over $20 million, likely around $24 million. The consultants estimated an
investment from 1.7MM to 2.3MM for 500 employees, which I believe is a
conservative estimate. I also believe that training would be required for a
much large number of employees than 500, likely closer to several thousand, as
well as the likely possibility we would need to hire additional personnel. The
consultants estimated an additional 15MM would likely be needed to fully
support a several year implementation
with additional personnel and training. I would also like to
reiterate the loss of productivity costs that would occur while employees are
removed from daily duties for training as well as the learning curve
associated with its daily application, which could be one of the larger costs
associated with the possible upgrade.
Secondly, as I wrote of in my initial insights we have set
numerous industry standards and even best practices as a result of overhaul of
our IT system from 2001-2008 and even through today. The consultants, who
obviously are a third party hired to give an objective view of our practices
and where we can improve stated a considerable number of areas where we are
considered state-of-the art and contain a stable IT business structure to
support the needs of the business. From this, we can infer that a number of the
COBIT 5 standards have virtually already been set in place here at Accenture and
would not yield a great advantage from where we currently stand. Furthermore, the
current IT model we operate with is very complex and sophisticated while COBIT
5 offers more of a general model to create and operate an IT framework. COBIT 5
would likely have been a viable option before our complete overhaul as a
foundation for our future IT framework, however with a complex IT system
already in place I do not believe COBIT 5 standards are a specific fit for our
business at the current time. I also believe that we need to strongly consider
potential backlash from internal and external stakeholders who may not agree
with the investment. I’m sure there are number of investors and employees
internally who may not believe the investment is not needed at this time and
the capital could make a greater strategic impact elsewhere. Internally, there
are employees within the organization who have gone to great lengths while
working very intensely to build our current framework that has yielded great
success and moving in a different direction or making significant modifications
could create turbulence within the firm.
For these stated reasons I believe that now is not the correct
time for us to implement COBIT 5 standards here at Accenture. I do believe that
COBIT 5 is a proven successful model to infer knowledge from as we move forward
with further development and modifications with our IT infrastructure in the
future. As we move forward towards a final decision I would like to garner your
thoughts in regards to the consultant meeting and if anything has changed or was
reaffirmed from your initial insights into COBIT 5.
Thank you,
Brian Grau