Sunday, March 10, 2013

COBIT 5- Accenture Consultant follow-up


Team, 

As a follow up to our consultant meeting on the topic of a possible system implementation and upgrade to COBIT 5 I have the following thoughts before we move towards making a final decision. As stated in my initial pre-meeting notes and reiterated by the consultants, this is a major investment for our firm and is a significant decisions in regards of the future development and direction of our information technology systems. For several key reasons I still maintain the position that it is not the time for Accenture to go ahead with the implementation of COBIT 5 standards. 

It is important to remind ourselves the actual tangible benefit we could obtain versus the investment costs. When taking a closer look at the initial capital outlays plus future investments needed to maintain the COBIT 5 implementation I simply believe that the costs outweigh the benefits. My initial research provided insights into a total investment that could easily reach over $20 million, likely around $24 million. The consultants estimated an investment from 1.7MM to 2.3MM for 500 employees, which I believe is a conservative estimate. I also believe that training would be required for a much large number of employees than 500, likely closer to several thousand, as well as the likely possibility we would need to hire additional personnel. The consultants estimated an additional 15MM would likely be needed to fully support a several year implementation with additional personnel and training. I would also like to reiterate the loss of productivity costs that would occur while employees are removed from daily duties for training as well as the learning curve associated with its daily application, which could be one of the larger costs associated with the possible upgrade.

Secondly, as I wrote of in my initial insights we have set numerous industry standards and even best practices as a result of overhaul of our IT system from 2001-2008 and even through today. The consultants, who obviously are a third party hired to give an objective view of our practices and where we can improve stated a considerable number of areas where we are considered state-of-the art and contain a stable IT business structure to support the needs of the business. From this, we can infer that a number of the COBIT 5 standards have virtually already been set in place here at Accenture and would not yield a great advantage from where we currently stand. Furthermore, the current IT model we operate with is very complex and sophisticated while COBIT 5 offers more of a general model to create and operate an IT framework. COBIT 5 would likely have been a viable option before our complete overhaul as a foundation for our future IT framework, however with a complex IT system already in place I do not believe COBIT 5 standards are a specific fit for our business at the current time. I also believe that we need to strongly consider potential backlash from internal and external stakeholders who may not agree with the investment. I’m sure there are number of investors and employees internally who may not believe the investment is not needed at this time and the capital could make a greater strategic impact elsewhere. Internally, there are employees within the organization who have gone to great lengths while working very intensely to build our current framework that has yielded great success and moving in a different direction or making significant modifications could create turbulence within the firm.

For these stated reasons I believe that now is not the correct time for us to implement COBIT 5 standards here at Accenture. I do believe that COBIT 5 is a proven successful model to infer knowledge from as we move forward with further development and modifications with our IT infrastructure in the future. As we move forward towards a final decision I would like to garner your thoughts in regards to the consultant meeting and if anything has changed or was reaffirmed from your initial insights into COBIT 5.

Thank you,

Brian Grau

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Strategic IT Transformation at Accenture Consulting Lead In


Problem & Issue Statement: 

As Accenture implemented a state of the art and total overhaul of their information technology systems they quickly realized two things. First, the complete overhaul and ideology behind the path they chose for completing a complete transformation of the IT infrastructure, applications, suppliers, and software turned out to be extremely effective and successful. It's clear that very few organizations of that size could complete such a massive overhaul of their IT systems so quickly, dynamically, and completely. As an organization that genuinely believes and consults clients on simplifying processes and technology whenever possible, while also maintaining state-of-the-art industry leading technology and infrastructure this decision showed all current and prospective clients that Accenture truly believed in what they advise to its clients while setting an industry standard as it relates to IT infrastructure and transformation. Secondly, after solidifying and upgrading its IT systems, Accenture was strongly considering another upgrade to enhance its business standards & reporting as well as a total management of the business framework and enterprise systems. The framework software that Accenture was considering for the upgrade was COBIT 5. Even with a sophisticated IT system now in place Accenture had to consider its financial reporting systems among countless regulations across the globe. On top of regulations and compliance standards COBIT 5 could also possibly enhance Accenture's ability for their IT systems and applications to better communicate leading to greater integration, information access, and ultimately more sound business decisions. The IT overhaul of the IT system focused in on four key areas. These included: 1) redefining IT at Accenture from a cost center to an actual business model 2) reducing IT spending through an implementation of a web-enabled technology solution such as Microsoft or SAP 3) greater IT governance and oversight based on key strategic business objectives and lastly 4) a single-vendor/single-platform approach to software and applications eliminating the need for multiple suppliers while increasing buying power. COBIT 5 seeks to streamline these objectives through a detailed framework of best practices centered on a principles, polices, and framework ideology.

Plausible solutions & assessment: 

Accenture is ultimately considering two plausible solutions to the issue at hand; continue with the current IT framework and structure or implement COBIT 5 standards.

Continuing with their current IT framework and management system would ensure that Accenture would be maintaining the system that made them so successful from 2001 to today. When Accenture moved forward with the implementation of an upgraded IT system a number of key metrics improved across the organization. As a ratio to net revenue Accenture decreased IT spending by 58% (60% decrease of IT spend/employee) while nearly doubling revenues at the same time. Furthermore, local applications had been cut by 87% from the levels they were in 2001 before the upgrade while also maintaining high levels of satisfaction among employees internally and earning praise from external stakeholders. By choosing to forgo the COBIT 5 implementation and maintaining the status quo of their IT system, Accenture could continue to see their IT spending decrease dramatically, a functional or even exceptional level of integration as it currently operates, as well as the ability to continue the use of a decreased number of suppliers and applications needed to conduct business operations. Accenture could also continue to lean on their existing value chain and reporting systems that virtually revolve around the clock while ‘following the sun.’

Implementing COBIT 5 standards could result in several added benefits to their current IT system, but would also need a sizeable investment and change in current practices already in place. COBIT 5 has a number of similarities to their current IT model, with several practices that seem to overlap. COBIT 5 strives to create efficiencies, control, and flexibility in key IT areas such as plan & organize, acquire & implement, delivery & support, and monitor & evaluate. Within these areas or IT domains, COBIT 5 has proven outlines and best practices that can minimize unwarranted software’s and applications, link software and applications directly to business procedures and reporting, and an overall reduction of IT spending; among other benefits. It would be extremely important for Accenture to carefully identify each key benefit COBIT 5 has to offer and ensure that practice does not already exist within Accenture’s current framework. Implementing COBIT 5 involves a significant investment. A main cost structure for adopting COBIT 5 revolves around the training for employees which include costs of materials and in depth classroom setting training. The cost is roughly $175/employee for materials and another $1,500 for the two day class. Accenture would also need to consider other factors such as employee downtime and travel expenses. Conservatively, we could estimate the cost per employee who trains for COBIT 5 standards at roughly $2,500 each. Furthermore, there would be the time to implement and master the practices learned within the classroom and transfer them into every day practices at the office resulting in great loss of productivity. Even though everyone in the organization would not be subject to the training, an investment of at least $2,500 per employee across the IT function of thousands of employees is a significant investment.

Recommendation:

When fully considering the investment needed to adopt COBIT 5 standards along with its associated risk versus the tangible benefits Accenture could benefit from I believe it is not in the best interest of the organization to implement COBIT 5. With an investment that could exceed $20 million in costs, training, and loss of productivity as well as potential backlash from stakeholders that have taken a keen interest in Accenture’s industry standard IT systems and processes, the risk simply outweighs the net benefits that Accenture could utilize. Ultimately, even though COBIT 5 has industry-proven best practices and applications, Accenture’s current model already has in place a number of these practices and standards and implementing COBIT 5 would virtually duplicate existing measures already taken. For example, as previously stated COBIT 5 seeks to diminish replication among platforms, applications, and processes leading to decrease IT spending. This practice through the one-vendor and single-platform type approaches has been in place and has already streamlined processes and reduced costs significantly. COBIT 5 also seeks greater control over IT governance and control among regulations and standards however Accenture has these areas covered. They have put in place a series of controls such as project sponsors who see a project through all phases as well as a ROI auditing process that ensures accuracy and an upholding of standards and regulations. A number of further COBIT 5 standards were also covered through Accenture’s IT system overhaul such as linking IT processes to the objectives of the business through processes such as IT support on a per needs basis through an ‘internal customer’ and their need for the support. I believe that the upgrade is not warranted at this time as number of the key functions of COBIT 5 have already been in place since the overhaul in 2001. COBIT 5 provides keen insights into continually evolving our IT structure to consider as our business evolves over time, however the implementation given its investment is not a prudent choice at this time. 


Monday, March 4, 2013

Zara IT & POS Channel Reflective


Team, 

Overall great job in terms of preparation and attention to detail in regards to our meeting with the consultants last week. I believe the meeting with the consulting team created and developed a needed focus on the topic of our potential upgrade to our IT infrastructure and POS Channels within our outlets. There are a number of issues I would like for us to concentrate on and further discuss as we move forward towards our final decision. No matter the solution that we choose to move forward with I cannot stress the importance of this decision and the potential impacts (both positive and negative) that it could have on the immediate and future impact on our business and I hope each of will take considerable amount of time to consider the 'devil’s advocate' point of view with each of your decision factors.  

As I look back at the meeting there were a few surprises in regards to some of the content, although they confirmed much of the initial research and indicators I have seen. I felt as though the portion of the presentation regarding the various operating software’s we could consider was rather intriguing. The consultants provided a great deal of background into various OS's and custom application firms that we could consider if that route is chosen; all of which could be an asset in our future decision making. At times during the presentation I felt our team was questioning the validity to certain assumptions or subject expertise on certain criteria the consultants were covering, which is greatly encouraged, however it does show that perhaps we should take a moment of pause. Due to the size of the investment and the potential impact it has on our business model we need to consider every possibility and not have any lingering doubts or questions in regards to the decision. I enjoyed the manner in which the consultants presented the entirety of the situation and injected their previous working knowledge to add to their presentation as well. They were obviously advocating for us to move away from our DOS OS to a new system within Linux or Windows in a phased deployment along with an upgrade to our hardware and POS channels from a third party vendor. The consultants provided these arguments with solid cost analysis, switching costs, and vendors that we could move forward with given the decision. It would have been prudent for the consultants to offer greater detail in the possible decision to stay with our current systems and discuss the benefits and risks within that solution as well.

I, after further careful consideration, fundamentally disagree with a decision to upgrade from our current DOS OS and POS channels at this specific time. I believe that the potential risk we face is simply far greater than the possible benefits of the upgrade. As I mentioned prior to the consultant meeting, there is an inherited risk of maintaining our current systems moving forward into the future given our contractual issues with our main supplier of our hardware components.  I am also fully aware of the benefits the upgrade would bring in allowing our IT infrastructure & software to become up-to-date, almost state-of-the-art. Wireless networking, increased functionality in our handhelds, inter-store communication, actual and live inventory counts, sales information, and decrease transmission time and an increase in communication between our HQ and outlets are some of the features. All of these are great features to have within an IT system, however they do not provide a great deal of actual strategic growth for our firm. I look at this potential upgrade not in terms of future growth, but rather a hedge against the risk of a finite supply of our current hardware. These features described above are not necessities within our business model as we have shown through our tremendous growth into various markets using our current systems. We have been quoted ourselves are stating ‘close is good enough’ and ‘being too accurate is costly’ in regards to inventories. We flourish in a model that focuses on timely, market driven demands and quick turnarounds with little inventory back stock. It is not considered imperative to have our outlet staff monitoring exact details of stock or sending inventories within outlets; we need them on the floor selling!

I do however fully acknowledge the need to eventually upgrade our systems at some point in the future as I believe the capabilities and benefits associated with an upgrade will continue to grow and eventually outweigh the massive risk of employee and outlet down time resulting in possibly loss of sales in the millions. I believe this is a viable option to consider as an option to implement in the future given our predicament with our suppliers. At this current time I believe it is in within our best interest to exert our buying power and scale on our current suppliers to create a long-term contract to produce our current equipment as we are their largest customer.

I look forward to discussing this matter with the team in greater detail as we move towards a final decision.

Regards,

Brian Grau 

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Ubuntu Implementation


Good Evening Sir, 

As per your request for an evaluation of the Ubuntu operating system as well as the risks and benefits associated with a possible migration from Windows I have the provided the following assessment. Ubuntu is the world's largest Linux distribution, created in 2004 by Canonical, focusing on simplicity and frequent software updates. I would consider Ubuntu to be use-friendly software with a large amount of applications and a operating system interface similar to Windows. It comes with it's own versions of the most popular business applications similar to Window's Word, PowerPoint, etc, but not overwhelmingly different in nature. It has become evident that through initial research that Ubuntu does offer potential benefits that I believe our organization could utilize while also at the same time providing an inherited risk associated with the implementation. The key question is whether or not the benefits of the installation stack up to the amount of risk with making a complete switch the Ubuntu OS. Although Ubuntu is an interesting alternative to consider I believe the financial and opportunity or 'switching' costs outweigh the actual tangible benefits we could see in our bottom line. 

First, I believe it is important to note the financial impact the implementation could potentially have on the organization. At an initial glance it may appear there is a significant financial gain that could be made by moving from Windows OS (and its licensing fees) and its bevy of office applications to the open-sourced and free Ubuntu OS. However, we must be prudent and consider things such as sunk, opportunity, and switching costs. We analyzing our licensing fees with Microsoft for it's OS and office applications we can negotiate favorable bulk contracting prices due to the size of the licenses we are purchasing for installation on every computer across the organization. Currently as the most popular OS in the world, particularly in the home office and business sector, Microsoft enjoys the capability of virtually tying its operating system into nearly every PC and laptop sold through a variety of channels. Several manufactures do not sell PC’s or laptops without a pre-installed operating system (virtually always Windows OS). If we were to purchase Windows 7 OS ‘over the counter’ from an outlet or online retailer the average price is right around $95. Due to our licensing agreements and contract negotiation due to the size of the firm this price can be decreased up to 10%. Furthermore, purchasing a PC or laptop without an OS does not necessarily mean we will save 100% of the average Windows 7 OS price. The marginal savings of purchasing a computer for new employees without an operating software package would average $45-50. If the firm were to grow by 300 new employees this fiscal year we would save $15,00 in operating system costs. In terms of Microsoft office, current licenses of Office 365 Professional are being sold for roughly $400 ($400 X 200 = $80,000). When extrapolating these costs over time savings do multiply; however when compared to the overall risks they appear to be marginal, as well as the fact that we are considering utilizing Office Home 365 Premium which is only $99. It is important to note that there are certain upgrade and renewal fees associated with Microsoft licensing that Ubuntu currently does not charge. The cost of the Windows 7 already purchased or are contracted to be purchased are classified as sunk costs and cannot be recouped, and those sunk costs would be wasted if we were to move each PC or laptop to Ubuntu. Furthermore, we would need to consider that Microsoft does offer substantial tech and live-phone support for our employees given any issues or concerns with an application or software that Ubuntu does not offer. The migration towards Ubuntu would likely require formal training, although minimal, further depleting the cost savings with the switch. This would require an investment of classroom-type training for virtually all 30,000 global employees.

When further analyzing the benefits and risks of migrating to Ubuntu it is important to consider the switching and opportunity costs as well. These costs revolve around lost productivity of employees and the opportunity to pursue other projects or training in place of the switch the Ubuntu. When considering a loss of productivity measure we could fairly assume that overwhelming (if not all) of our employees could be considered as tech-savvy to moderate in terms of utilizing the functions of the operating system they currently use. To gain a strong understanding of the basic functions, locations, differences, features, and applications Ubuntu offers we could estimate each employee may lose on average 2.5 hours of productivity as compared to continuing the same workload on their current software. An average salary of $40/hour at 2.5 hours results in estimate productivity loss of $3 million across 30,000 global employees.

When considering the switch from Windows to Ubuntu it is extremely important to consider all of the costs and savings that apply. I believe that when examining the sunk and switching costs associated with the migration they outweigh the financial cost savings with the switch with a company of our size. Also, with so many client facings roles as we currently employee we would need to consider if there would be possible back lash from our clients that we present to and interface with on a daily basis in regards to switching from Windows. There is an intangible savings or value with continuing the use of a program that our employees are extremely comfortable working with and we run the risk of tremendous backlash internally with the switch on such a large scale. Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, even though Ubuntu does offer a number of benefits with the continual upgrades and overall simplicity, I do not see the actual benefit that would strategically drive our company forward in the future by moving away from an OS and applications that virtually every single one of customers and all of our employees use on a daily basis, when considering that the cost savings are marginal.

I look forward to discussing this matter in greater detail.

Regards,

Brian Grau