Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Pandora Case Prep

Pandora's management team faced several difficult decisions to make just as the company seemed to be turning the road into profitability and substantial market share. One may believe that Pandora could simply stick to the model it's currently operating given the promising forecast of profitability and stability that the company has shown over the last several years; however with success also came opposing strategies to weigh and consider. Founder and creator of Pandora, Tim Westergren, had to balance competing interests, investor relations, profitability & growth, as well as his own visions and aspirations for the company. It became quite evident to Tim Westergren that the strategies he would enact would have an immediate and long-lasting impact on Pandora.

With currently over 8 million listeners, an online hour growth rate of 50% per year, and a business model that satisfies virtually endless customer segments, it was obvious Pandora was becoming a very successful company.  Ironically, however, even though Pandora was looking to turn the corner towards profitability, the company would actually be near cash-strapped into the next fiscal year given its current operations. Even while stepping down form the CEO position, Tim Westergren still desperately wanted to keep his vision of the live-streaming radio application alive, but still understood he had the interests of investors to consider as well as the need for cash to operate the company. Even though Pandora has proven their medal to advertisers through significant marketing and advertising metrics ($10-13 CPM) as well as millions of loyal customers, some investors doubted the ability of Pandora to leverage those opportunities and turn it into serious profits. Besides investors, Pandora had the threat of increasing royalties looming large, a potential increase that could pull the cash-stabbed business under. Pandora showed the strength of its following and loyalty of its customer base by the millions of letters that were petitioned against the royalty increase. Pandora faced a variety of strategies that could be chosen to generate added revenues such as increasing advertising on the service, seek new mediums and sources of data in regards to customers to increase its advertising value, or create a subscription fee for a premium or varying levels of service.

Possible Alternatives:

First, Pandora could consider moving forward in the direction of generating increased revenues through ads. An increase in on-screen advertising could help form strategic partnerships with varying advertisers (concert venues or affiliate retailers) while offering greater ad space, thus increasing revenues focusing on click trough’s, in turn generating greater revenue for Pandora. Given the proven metrics, Pandora could certainly attract potential advertisers with the increased ad availability; however it does come with certain consequences. Pandora's growth rate of subscribers would certainly slow given the word-of-mouth of increase of ads on the service  and could also possibly turn-off a portion of listeners who are looking for a service with strictly music. Pandora could optionally put in place a tiered advertising structure within this strategy. To limit potential backlash from the increase in advertising Pandora could offer the ability to customers to create more comprehensive customer profiles or greater feedback in terms of the music they were listening to. This feedback would in turn provide fewer ads to that particular customer in exchange for a greater amount of information on that customer. The increased demographic and preference information would then lead to more accurate radio service and increase targeted advertising for Pandora.

Pandora could also chose a variation of the first possible recommendation by increasing customer information, while not increasing ad space. At the time of sign up and periodically throughout the life of a customer using the service Pandora could seek additional valuable customer demographic and profile information. Pandora could limit potential backlash of these surveys by informing customers it is being enacted as a way to keep ads limited and the service free of charge. Currently, Pandora operates with relatively simple and basic customer information during profile creation and throughout its use, as well as basic information in regards to listener’s music preference (thumbs up or down). By enacting more comprehensive surveys, demographics and customer feedback on preferences Pandora could leverage that information from millions of consumers to increase advertising revenues as it currently operates. Even an increase of $2.00 (from 10-13 to 12-15 CPM) could result in a 20% increase of revenues.

Furthermore, Pandora could opt towards a balance of increasing advertising space while also offering a premium ad-free option to consumers. This option would certainly alienate certain customers, and would slow the rate of growth as well. At the same time to counteract this, Pandora would generate revenues through subscription fees as well as increased advertising. A $5/month premium subscription fee over 5 million users could generate upwards or $25 Million in additional revenues. This premium service would entail zero ad space on the accounts as well as an unlimited number of click-troughs on streaming songs. In this instance, Pandora would have to leverage its massive music library and brand name to attract as many subscriptions as possible.

Recommendation/Presentation:
There are seamlessly an endless number of strategies or combinations of strategies Pandora could deploy in order to balance the differing interests internally and externally. I believe it would be in Pandora’s greatest interest to move towards an increased ad-model while at the same time offering tiered subscriptions to limit or remove those advertisements depending on that customer’s specific preference. This would allow the customer to individually choose the levels of data and advertising they wish while factoring in subscriptions fees. I believe that the wealth of consumer knowledge, market share, and business model is put to waste if it is not leveraged as a fine line on advertising. Pandora must ensure that customers know that this decision is only being made for the viability of the music streaming service that is enjoyed by millions and every effort will be made to keep advertising and subscription fees as low as possible. As part of the presentation to the board I would also introduce the smaller-scale strategies of making the organization leaner by automating certain processes such as ‘music coding’ through a custom software package, thus in term shirking the employee base. Furthermore, Pandora could leverage the massive support and intrigue it receives from 'no-name' or up and coming artist looking to break onto the scene. Countless artists try and break through into their niche markets without a major record label by having their music displayed on Pandora. Without moving towards a major record status, Pandora could still leverage this support into revenues through 'placement-fees' by adding the artist’s music on the service as one of the few ways in reaching main-stream.

No comments:

Post a Comment