Problem & Issue Statement:
As Accenture implemented
a state of the art and total overhaul of their information technology systems they
quickly realized two things. First, the complete overhaul and ideology behind
the path they chose for completing a complete transformation of the IT
infrastructure, applications, suppliers, and software turned out to be
extremely effective and successful. It's clear that very few organizations of
that size could complete such a massive overhaul of their IT systems so quickly,
dynamically, and completely. As an organization that genuinely believes
and consults clients on simplifying processes and technology whenever possible,
while also maintaining state-of-the-art industry leading technology and
infrastructure this decision showed all current and prospective clients that
Accenture truly believed in what they advise to its clients while setting an
industry standard as it relates to IT infrastructure and transformation.
Secondly, after solidifying and upgrading its IT systems, Accenture was
strongly considering another upgrade to enhance its business standards &
reporting as well as a total management of the business framework and
enterprise systems. The framework software that Accenture was considering for
the upgrade was COBIT 5. Even with a sophisticated IT system now in place
Accenture had to consider its financial reporting systems among countless
regulations across the globe. On top of regulations and compliance standards
COBIT 5 could also possibly enhance Accenture's ability for their IT systems
and applications to better communicate leading to greater integration,
information access, and ultimately more sound business decisions. The IT
overhaul of the IT system focused in on four key areas. These included: 1) redefining
IT at Accenture from a cost center to an actual business model 2) reducing IT
spending through an implementation of a web-enabled technology solution such as
Microsoft or SAP 3) greater IT governance and oversight based on key strategic
business objectives and lastly 4) a single-vendor/single-platform approach to
software and applications eliminating the need for multiple suppliers while
increasing buying power. COBIT 5 seeks to streamline these objectives through a
detailed framework of best practices centered on a principles, polices, and framework
ideology.
Plausible solutions & assessment:
Accenture is ultimately
considering two plausible solutions to the issue at hand; continue with the
current IT framework and structure or implement COBIT 5 standards.
Continuing with their
current IT framework and management system would ensure that Accenture would be
maintaining the system that made them so successful from 2001 to today. When Accenture
moved forward with the implementation of an upgraded IT system a number of key
metrics improved across the organization. As a ratio to net revenue Accenture
decreased IT spending by 58% (60% decrease of IT spend/employee) while nearly
doubling revenues at the same time. Furthermore, local applications had been
cut by 87% from the levels they were in 2001 before the upgrade while also maintaining
high levels of satisfaction among employees internally and earning praise from
external stakeholders. By choosing to forgo the COBIT 5 implementation and maintaining
the status quo of their IT system, Accenture could continue to see their IT
spending decrease dramatically, a functional or even exceptional level of
integration as it currently operates, as well as the ability to continue the
use of a decreased number of suppliers and applications needed to conduct
business operations. Accenture could also continue to lean on their existing
value chain and reporting systems that virtually revolve around the clock while
‘following the sun.’
Implementing COBIT 5
standards could result in several added benefits to their current IT system, but
would also need a sizeable investment and change in current practices already
in place. COBIT 5 has a number of similarities to their current IT model, with
several practices that seem to overlap. COBIT 5 strives to create efficiencies,
control, and flexibility in key IT areas such as plan & organize, acquire
& implement, delivery & support, and monitor & evaluate. Within these
areas or IT domains, COBIT 5 has proven outlines and best practices that can minimize
unwarranted software’s and applications, link software and applications
directly to business procedures and reporting, and an overall reduction of IT
spending; among other benefits. It would be extremely important for Accenture
to carefully identify each key benefit COBIT 5 has to offer and ensure that
practice does not already exist within Accenture’s current framework.
Implementing COBIT 5 involves a significant investment. A main cost structure
for adopting COBIT 5 revolves around the training for employees which include
costs of materials and in depth classroom setting training. The cost is roughly $175/employee for materials
and another $1,500 for the two day class. Accenture would also need to consider
other factors such as employee downtime and travel expenses. Conservatively, we
could estimate the cost per employee who trains for COBIT 5 standards at
roughly $2,500 each. Furthermore, there would be the time to implement and
master the practices learned within the classroom and transfer them into every
day practices at the office resulting in great loss of productivity. Even though
everyone in the organization would not be subject to the training, an
investment of at least $2,500 per employee across the IT function of thousands
of employees is a significant investment.
Recommendation:
When fully considering
the investment needed to adopt COBIT 5 standards along with its associated risk
versus the tangible benefits Accenture could benefit from I believe it is not
in the best interest of the organization to implement COBIT 5. With an
investment that could exceed $20 million in costs, training, and loss of productivity
as well as potential backlash from stakeholders that have taken a keen interest
in Accenture’s industry standard IT systems and processes, the risk simply outweighs
the net benefits that Accenture could utilize. Ultimately, even though COBIT 5
has industry-proven best practices and applications, Accenture’s current model already
has in place a number of these practices and standards and implementing COBIT 5
would virtually duplicate existing measures already taken. For example, as
previously stated COBIT 5 seeks to diminish replication among platforms,
applications, and processes leading to decrease IT spending. This practice
through the one-vendor and single-platform type approaches has been in place
and has already streamlined processes and reduced costs significantly. COBIT 5
also seeks greater control over IT governance and control among regulations and
standards however Accenture has these areas covered. They have put in place a
series of controls such as project sponsors who see a project through all
phases as well as a ROI auditing process that ensures accuracy and an upholding
of standards and regulations. A number of further COBIT 5 standards were also
covered through Accenture’s IT system overhaul such as linking IT processes to
the objectives of the business through processes such as IT support on a per
needs basis through an ‘internal customer’ and their need for the support. I
believe that the upgrade is not warranted at this time as number of the key
functions of COBIT 5 have already been in place since the overhaul in 2001.
COBIT 5 provides keen insights into continually evolving our IT structure to
consider as our business evolves over time, however the implementation given its
investment is not a prudent choice at this time.
No comments:
Post a Comment