Sunday, March 3, 2013

Ubuntu Implementation


Good Evening Sir, 

As per your request for an evaluation of the Ubuntu operating system as well as the risks and benefits associated with a possible migration from Windows I have the provided the following assessment. Ubuntu is the world's largest Linux distribution, created in 2004 by Canonical, focusing on simplicity and frequent software updates. I would consider Ubuntu to be use-friendly software with a large amount of applications and a operating system interface similar to Windows. It comes with it's own versions of the most popular business applications similar to Window's Word, PowerPoint, etc, but not overwhelmingly different in nature. It has become evident that through initial research that Ubuntu does offer potential benefits that I believe our organization could utilize while also at the same time providing an inherited risk associated with the implementation. The key question is whether or not the benefits of the installation stack up to the amount of risk with making a complete switch the Ubuntu OS. Although Ubuntu is an interesting alternative to consider I believe the financial and opportunity or 'switching' costs outweigh the actual tangible benefits we could see in our bottom line. 

First, I believe it is important to note the financial impact the implementation could potentially have on the organization. At an initial glance it may appear there is a significant financial gain that could be made by moving from Windows OS (and its licensing fees) and its bevy of office applications to the open-sourced and free Ubuntu OS. However, we must be prudent and consider things such as sunk, opportunity, and switching costs. We analyzing our licensing fees with Microsoft for it's OS and office applications we can negotiate favorable bulk contracting prices due to the size of the licenses we are purchasing for installation on every computer across the organization. Currently as the most popular OS in the world, particularly in the home office and business sector, Microsoft enjoys the capability of virtually tying its operating system into nearly every PC and laptop sold through a variety of channels. Several manufactures do not sell PC’s or laptops without a pre-installed operating system (virtually always Windows OS). If we were to purchase Windows 7 OS ‘over the counter’ from an outlet or online retailer the average price is right around $95. Due to our licensing agreements and contract negotiation due to the size of the firm this price can be decreased up to 10%. Furthermore, purchasing a PC or laptop without an OS does not necessarily mean we will save 100% of the average Windows 7 OS price. The marginal savings of purchasing a computer for new employees without an operating software package would average $45-50. If the firm were to grow by 300 new employees this fiscal year we would save $15,00 in operating system costs. In terms of Microsoft office, current licenses of Office 365 Professional are being sold for roughly $400 ($400 X 200 = $80,000). When extrapolating these costs over time savings do multiply; however when compared to the overall risks they appear to be marginal, as well as the fact that we are considering utilizing Office Home 365 Premium which is only $99. It is important to note that there are certain upgrade and renewal fees associated with Microsoft licensing that Ubuntu currently does not charge. The cost of the Windows 7 already purchased or are contracted to be purchased are classified as sunk costs and cannot be recouped, and those sunk costs would be wasted if we were to move each PC or laptop to Ubuntu. Furthermore, we would need to consider that Microsoft does offer substantial tech and live-phone support for our employees given any issues or concerns with an application or software that Ubuntu does not offer. The migration towards Ubuntu would likely require formal training, although minimal, further depleting the cost savings with the switch. This would require an investment of classroom-type training for virtually all 30,000 global employees.

When further analyzing the benefits and risks of migrating to Ubuntu it is important to consider the switching and opportunity costs as well. These costs revolve around lost productivity of employees and the opportunity to pursue other projects or training in place of the switch the Ubuntu. When considering a loss of productivity measure we could fairly assume that overwhelming (if not all) of our employees could be considered as tech-savvy to moderate in terms of utilizing the functions of the operating system they currently use. To gain a strong understanding of the basic functions, locations, differences, features, and applications Ubuntu offers we could estimate each employee may lose on average 2.5 hours of productivity as compared to continuing the same workload on their current software. An average salary of $40/hour at 2.5 hours results in estimate productivity loss of $3 million across 30,000 global employees.

When considering the switch from Windows to Ubuntu it is extremely important to consider all of the costs and savings that apply. I believe that when examining the sunk and switching costs associated with the migration they outweigh the financial cost savings with the switch with a company of our size. Also, with so many client facings roles as we currently employee we would need to consider if there would be possible back lash from our clients that we present to and interface with on a daily basis in regards to switching from Windows. There is an intangible savings or value with continuing the use of a program that our employees are extremely comfortable working with and we run the risk of tremendous backlash internally with the switch on such a large scale. Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, even though Ubuntu does offer a number of benefits with the continual upgrades and overall simplicity, I do not see the actual benefit that would strategically drive our company forward in the future by moving away from an OS and applications that virtually every single one of customers and all of our employees use on a daily basis, when considering that the cost savings are marginal.

I look forward to discussing this matter in greater detail.

Regards,

Brian Grau

No comments:

Post a Comment